CENTURY 21 Preferred Realty, Inc.

Your Neighborhood Realtor with the National Brand

Century 21 Preferred Realty was established in 1991 with the Tradition of Trust, and Dedication to Results under the ownership of Jeff Montemarano.   Backed by the strength and support of The Century 21 brand, we pledge to serve our clients with the highest standards of professionalism, courtesy and responsiveness.  Through years of innovation, service and support, Century 21 Preferred Realty has earned the loyalty of buyers and sellers who look to the firm for all their real estate needs.  Our commitment to honesty, integrity and superior customer service exemplify our success. 

It is the mission of Century 21 Preferred Realty to uphold the highest standards of integrity by providing the finest service ever offered by any real estate organization.

Connect with us!
Butler, NJ
Real Estate Market Information
Homes Owned: 2,148
Homes Rented: 971
Median Home Price: $291,500
Area Schools: 9
Best Score: 5/10
Average Score: 3.3

Our Listings

Search all our property listings

Our Agents

Meet the CENTURY 21 Preferred Realty, Inc. Team

Customer Testimonial

William Roberts

Buyer Rating:

Bill Roberts takes the time to not only show you homes but to explain why these homes are practical for your family. He took the time to show my family and I homes until we found one that worked for us. Bill & I had conversation regarding the pros vs. cons of homes and at no point did I feel like he was just selling me something, I felt like he was helping me make an educated decision that was best for my family. He gave me all of the knowledge and tools that I needed to make an informed decision regarding my families future.

This guy is great and not only my realtor but now a friend! - Christopher Dooney September 2017

Joshua Waer

Seller Rating:

Josh was the perfect representative to sell our house. He is passionate about his work and made the process stressfree. I would suggest Josh as an agent to al of myl friends and family. - The Lavers Nj September 2017

Noralisa Santiago

Buyer Rating:

Noralisa Santiago made every step as easy as possible. All our questions and concerned were always answered. Her attention to detail is phenomenal, as well as her knowledge of the areas we searched. She is an exceptional realtor! My husband and I feel privileged to have her as our realtor and now friend. We are forever thankful. - John And Lismari Garramu August 2017

Sarah Mazzella

Buyer Rating:

When we started to look for homes our first realtor was always busy and never seem to find us any good homes, we were bascially finding our own homes. Sarah Mazzella was recommended by our Broker, he had called me to let me know that he had given our information to Sarah Mazzella and that she will be calling me soon. She called that same day, I had explain what our budget was and what we were looking for, Within an hour she had a listing of houses for us to review. I couldn't believe how fast she worked on finding us houses.

Sarah Mazzella took us to all the houses that we were interested in. She did have patience for us because I was picky in certain houses, she knew right away if I liked the house or not. She would not pressure us into buying the house, she always worked super hard to find us the right home.

She was very professional and very friendly. Sarah Mazzella will always be our go to realtor. She will be the one I recommend to all my friends and family. She is the best realtor to have when finding a home. Best recommendation ever. - Aleyda Enriquez, Wanaque July 2017

Michelle Reith

Seller Rating:

Michelle Reith is a personal friend and did the best job she could do to sell this property. I would recommend Michelle Reith to any other friend or family member in the area.

Thanks - Rick Ball, Ellicott City April 2017

Lynn Schiffman

Buyer Rating:

Lynn Schiffman was fantastic !! would love to work with her again in the future !!

I was a first time buyer and couldn't of asked for a better realtor !!

A ++

Truthful, Honest, polite and went above and beyond !! - Daniel Perez March 2017

Megan Johnson

Buyer Rating:

Meghan was with me during my whole first homebuying experience. She was friendly, knowledgeable, and always willing to help and clarify on things that I didn't quite understand. She was easy to reach and even reached out to me a few times to make sure that everything was going well and to offer to lend her hand if there was anything that I needed. Megan is truly a professional and I'm so happy to of had the chance to work with her. - Brian Hoesly, Wharton February 2017

Jo-Anne Mitchell

Seller Rating:

Joanne Caruso is a pleasure and delight. She is harding working and knowledgable.

I would high recommend her. - Linda Ricupero, Woodland December 2015

Linda Hendricks

Seller Rating:

She is thorough, relentless and professional - None Of Your Business December 2015

William Roberts

Seller Rating:

Bill's input as to pricing and preparing the house for sale were invaluable. He knew exactly what would work, and it did. - Mark A. Durstewitz David May 2017

Joshua Waer

Buyer Rating:

Josh was extremely helpful throughout the entire process of buying our first home. He is very knowledgeable and professional. He had an answer for almost every question we had; and if he didn't know, he would find out and get back to us right away. He was also very patient and kind. We did not feel like we were being pushed into a house that wasn't right for us. He really listened to what we wanted in a house and delivered. We are very happy with the entire experience and would highly recommend Josh to family, friends, and anyone else that is looking to buy a home! Thank you, Josh!! - C. Mckenna, Netcong, Nj May 2015

Sarah Mazzella

Seller Rating:

Sarah was very knowledgeable and friendly. She exceeded our expectations for sale price and speed of sale. We would highly recommend Sarah for anyone looking to buy or sell a home. She helped make what we thought would be an arduous and difficult journey into a quick and easy resolution! Thank you again Sarah!! - Elaine And Charles Worde May 2017

Michelle Reith

Buyer Rating:

I would definitely recommend Michelle Reith to anyone who is looking to sell/buy the house. She was very understanding and patient with us. - Yunna Bukas October 2016

Lynn Schiffman

Seller Rating:

Lynn is as awesome and kept in vtouch with me every step of the he way. She was kind and patient, and I couldn't have got through this process without her. I met a true friend for life and would 100% come to her again. Thank you for everything Lynn and everyone else who works with her in her office. Anne Bock

Above and beyond!!( - Anne Bock, Bloomingdale, November 2016

Megan Johnson

Buyer Rating:

Megan Johnson is a very nice person.. She helped us through this whole process of buying our 1 st home.. we are very happy that Megan Johnson was our realtor.. we will recommend her .. - Elaine And Krzysztof Fer February 2017

William Roberts

Buyer Rating:

Bill provided us with the appropriate advises that helped us to negotiate right. He showed us a number of comparable homes to educate us about what was in the market compared to what we were about to buy. Bill also treated our home purchase as if it was his own. He made sure that the inspection as well as the exchange of information between me and the seller were all done on a timely fashion without delays. He was constantly following up with all parties involved in this sales transaction. I personally felt that I am dealing with someone who cared to provide a good sales experience to my family and I. We normally treat Bill as good caring friend instead of a one time salesman. We can't thank him enough for all trips and the time spent with us in the past 2+ years until we found the right house. - Nabil Basta, Boonton Tow April 2017

Sarah Mazzella

Buyer Rating:

Sally was wonderful to work with. I was always up-to-date with the process thanks to her. Additionally, she was a joy to communicate with and was very knowledgeable about all the aspects of the purchase of my home. - Paul Bruneau, Cedar Grov May 2017

Michelle Reith

Buyer Rating:

Michelle is an extremely talented and professional agent - Sue Salvatore Riverdale February 2016

Lynn Schiffman

Seller Rating:

Lynn Schiffman is professional who worked diligently to sell our our unit. We had a difficult market and some unique challenges to overcome. She is an excellent communicator staying in touch with us and offering advice and encouragement.

I highly recommend Lynn to anyone requiring real estate services. - Nick, Northampton Pa October 2016

Megan Johnson

Buyer Rating:

We were really satisfied with megan,she always went out of her way for us. - Jenny Bardis,oak Ridge November 2016

* After the client and agent affiliated with CENTURY 21® Real Estate LLC complete a transaction, the client may be asked to provide feedback to help the CENTURY 21® System and sales professionals continuously improve. The affiliated agent's Overall Rating is an average of all ratings the agent has received. The specific survey responses shown were selected by the agent and were authorized by the client for display purposes. Some customers who provided a testimonial may have received a Starbucks gift card from their CENTURY 21 Sales Professional as a thank you for completing the customer satisfaction survey.

Service Areas

Awosting
Blairstown
Cupsaw Lake
Erskine Lakes
Erskine
Fayson Lakes
Gordon Lakes
Greenwood Lake
Hackettstown
Haskell
Hewitt
High Crest
Kinnelon
Lindy Lake
Lionshead Lake
Mc Afee
Midvale
Mountain View
Packanack Lake
Pine Cliff Lake
Pines Lake
Pompton Falls
Pompton Junction
Preakness
Shady Lake
Skyline Lakes
Upper Greenwood Lake
West Milford Lakes
West Paterson

Butler Regional Office

1333 Route 23 South, Butler NJ 07405

Butler, NJ

Take a closer look

Closest Airport
Newark Liberty International
Closest College
WILLIAM PATERSON UNIVERSITY-NEW JERSEY
Closest Major Sports Team
NEW YORK GIANTS
Closest Junior College
BERKELEY COLLEGE-GARRET MOUNTAIN CAMPUS

Demographic Data | Butler, NJ

Median Age: 41.81
Married: 38%
Households: 3,119

Overview

Population by Sex
3,915 Male
3,854 Female

Occupancy Types
129 Vacant
2,148 Owned
971 Rented

Employment

White/Blue Collar Jobs
39% White Collar
61% Blue Collar

Transportation to Work
92% Drive
2% Public Transportation
4% Walk/Bike/Other
2% Work from Home